League One
 
Final
Southend United
Plymouth Argyle
2
3
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Coventry City
2
1
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Walsall
2
1
 
Final
Wycombe Wanderers
Plymouth Argyle
1
0
 
Final
Peterborough United
Plymouth Argyle
0
1
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Portsmouth
1
1
 
Final
Bradford City
Plymouth Argyle
0
0
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Rochdale
5
1
 
Final
Sunderland
Plymouth Argyle
2
0
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Luton Town
0
0
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Shrewsbury Town
2
1
 
Final
Fleetwood Town
Plymouth Argyle
2
0
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Bristol Rovers
2
2
 
Final
Blackpool
Plymouth Argyle
2
2
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Charlton Athletic
0
2
 
Final
Doncaster Rovers
Plymouth Argyle
2
0
 
Final
Gillingham
Plymouth Argyle
3
1
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Barnsley
0
3
 
Final
Accrington Stanley
Plymouth Argyle
5
1
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Scunthorpe United
3
2