Major League Soccer
 
Final
New York RB
New York City
1
0
 
Final
New York City
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
Final
New York City
Chicago Fire
3
1
 
Final
New England
New York City
0
2
 
Final
DC United
New York City
0
0
 
Final
New York City
Cincinnati
2
1
 
Final
New England
New York City
0
0
 
Final
New York City
Toronto FC
0
1
 
Final
New York City
Cincinnati
4
0
 
Final
Inter Miami
New York City
2
3
 
Final
New York City
DC United
4
1
 
Final
New York City
New England
1
2
 
Final
Orlando City SC
New York City
1
1
 
Final
Columbus Crew
New York City
3
1
 
Final
New York City
Montreal Impact
3
1
 
Final
Toronto FC
New York City
0
1
 
Final
New York City
New York RB
5
2
 
Final
Chicago Fire
New York City
3
4
 
Final
Orlando City SC
New York City
P 1
1
 Liga dos Campeões CONCACAF
 
Final
Tigres UANL
New York City
4
0