Major League Soccer
 
Final
New York City
Columbus Crew
4
1
 
Final
Columbus Crew
DC United
2
4
 
Final
Columbus Crew
Atlanta United
2
3
 
Final
Chicago Fire
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
Final
New York RB
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
Final
Columbus Crew
Seattle Sounders FC
1
2
 
Final
Columbus Crew
Cincinnati
3
2
 
Final
Orlando City SC
Columbus Crew
3
2
 
Final
Inter Miami
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
Final
Columbus Crew
New York RB
2
1
 
Final
New England
Columbus Crew
1
1
 
Final
Columbus Crew
CF Montréal
2
1
 Campeones Cup
 
Columbus Crew
Cruz Azul
 Major League Soccer
 
Final
Philadelphia Union
Columbus Crew
3
0
 
Final
Columbus Crew
Inter Miami
4
0
 
Final
Nashville SC
Columbus Crew
1
1
 
Final
Columbus Crew
New York RB
1
2
 
Final
Columbus Crew
Orlando City SC
3
2
 
Final
DC United
Columbus Crew
1
3
 
Final
Columbus Crew
Chicago Fire
2
0