League One
 
Final
Rotherham United
Accrington Stanley
1
0
 
Final
AFC Wimbledon
Rotherham United
0
1
 
Final
Sheffield Wednesday
Rotherham United
0
2
 
Final
Rotherham United
Wigan Athletic
1
1
 
Final
Rotherham United
Morecambe
2
0
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Rotherham United
0
1
 
Final
Shrewsbury Town
Rotherham United
0
0
 
Final
Rotherham United
Milton Keynes Dons
1
2
 Trofeo de la Football League Inglesa
 
Final
Hartlepool United
Rotherham United
2
P 2
 League One
 
Final
Wycombe Wanderers
Rotherham United
0
0
 
Final
Rotherham United
Lincoln City
2
1
 
Final
Rotherham United
Shrewsbury Town
0
3
 Trofeo de la Football League Inglesa
 
Pro
Rotherham United
Sutton United
4
2
 League One
 
Final
Rotherham United
Charlton Athletic
0
1
 
Final
Portsmouth
Rotherham United
3
0
 
Final
Rotherham United
Ipswich Town
1
0
 
Final
Burton Albion
Rotherham United
2
0
 
Final
Rotherham United
Oxford United
2
1
 
Final
Sunderland
Rotherham United
1
1
 
Final
Gillingham
Rotherham United
0
2