Major League Futbol
 
MS
New York City
Portland Timbers
0
1
 US Open Cup
 
MS
Orlando City SC
New York City
P 1
1
 Major League Futbol
 
MS
New York RB
New York City
2
1
 
MS
Colorado Rapids
New York City
1
2
 
MS
New York City
Sporting KC
3
1
 
MS
Real Salt Lake
New York City
3
1
 
MS
New York City
Houston Dynamo
3
2
 
MS
Atlanta United
New York City
2
1
 
MS
Cincinnati
New York City
1
4
 
MS
New York City
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
MS
New York City
New York RB
2
1
 
MS
Vancouver Whitecaps
New York City
1
3
 
MS
New York City
New England
2
1
 
MS
New York City
Toronto FC
1
1
 
MS
New York City
SJ Earthquakes
2
1
90'
Dallas
New York City
1
1
 
MS
New York City
Atlanta United
4
1
 
MS
New England
New York City
2
0
 
MS
Philadelphia Union
New York City
1
2
 
MS
New York City
Toronto FC
1
2