-
 
Final
New York City
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
New York City
New York RB
 
Vancouver Whitecaps
New York City
 
New York City
New England
 
New York City
Toronto FC
 
New York City
SJ Earthquakes
 
Dallas
New York City
 
New York City
Atlanta United
 
New England
New York City
 
Philadelphia Union
New York City