Piala US Open (Piala AS)
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Pittsburgh Riverhounds
1
0
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Atlanta United
2
3
 Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Sporting KC
0
1
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Orlando City SC
0
2
 
FT
Real Salt Lake
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Seattle Sounders FC
1
2
 
FT
Orlando City SC
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
FT
Chicago Fire
Columbus Crew
2
2
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Montreal Impact
2
1
 
FT
New York RB
Columbus Crew
2
3
 
FT
SJ Earthquakes
Columbus Crew
1
1
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Cincinnati
2
2
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Toronto FC
2
2
 
FT
New York City
Columbus Crew
1
0
 
FT
Cincinnati
Columbus Crew
1
3
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Chicago Fire
1
1
 
FT
Atlanta United
Columbus Crew
1
3
 
FT
Vancouver Whitecaps
Columbus Crew
1
1
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Philadelphia Union
2
0
 
FT
Toronto FC
Columbus Crew
1
0