Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
New York RB
Toronto FC
2
0
 Canadian Championship
 
FT
Ottawa Fury
Toronto FC
0
2
 Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
Toronto FC
Orlando City SC
1
1
 Canadian Championship
 
FT
Toronto FC
Ottawa Fury
3
0
 Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
Columbus Crew
Toronto FC
2
2
 Canadian Championship
 
Toronto FC
Montreal Impact
 Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
Toronto FC
Montreal Impact
2
1
 
FT
New England
Toronto FC
1
1
 
FT
Cincinnati
Toronto FC
1
5
 
FT
New York City
Toronto FC
1
1
 
FT
Toronto FC
Colorado Rapids
3
2
 Canadian Championship
 
FT
Montreal Impact
Toronto FC
1
0
 Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
Los Angeles FC
Toronto FC
1
1
 Canadian Championship
 
FT
Toronto FC
Montreal Impact
1
P 0
 Liga MLS Amerika
 
FT
Chicago Fire
Toronto FC
2
2
 
FT
Toronto FC
Columbus Crew
1
0
ET
Toronto FC
DC United
5
1
 
FT
New York City
Toronto FC
1
2
 
FT
Atlanta United
Toronto FC
1
2
 
FT
Seattle Sounders FC
Toronto FC
3
1