League Two
 
Final
Sutton United
Salford City
0
0
 
Final
Sutton United
Forest Green Rovers
1
1
 
Final
Bristol Rovers
Sutton United
2
0
 
Final
Hartlepool United
Sutton United
1
1
 
Final
Sutton United
Scunthorpe United
4
1
 
Final
Sutton United
Rochdale
3
0
 Trofeo de la Football League Inglesa
 
Final
Wigan Athletic
Sutton United
1
P 1
 League Two
 
Final
Walsall
Sutton United
1
0
 
Final
Swindon Town
Sutton United
2
1
 
Final
Sutton United
Tranmere Rovers
1
1
 
Final
Oldham Athletic
Sutton United
1
3
 
Final
Port Vale
Sutton United
2
0
 Trofeo de la Football League Inglesa
 
Pro
Rotherham United
Sutton United
4
2
 League Two
 
Final
Sutton United
Leyton Orient
1
0
 
Final
Mansfield Town
Sutton United
2
3
 
Final
Sutton United
Newport County
1
0
 
Final
Barrow
Sutton United
1
0
 
Final
Sutton United
Crawley Town
3
0
 
Final
Sutton United
Bradford City
1
4
 
Final
Harrogate Town
Sutton United
0
2