League One
 
Final
Rotherham United
Cheltenham Town
1
0
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Wigan Athletic
0
0
 
Final
AFC Wimbledon
Cheltenham Town
2
2
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Sunderland
2
1
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Fleetwood Town
2
0
 
Final
Wycombe Wanderers
Cheltenham Town
5
5
 
Final
Ipswich Town
Cheltenham Town
0
0
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Crewe Alexandra
1
2
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Doncaster Rovers
4
0
 
Final
Milton Keynes Dons
Cheltenham Town
3
1
 
Final
Morecambe
Cheltenham Town
1
3
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
AFC Wimbledon
3
1
 
Final
Plymouth Argyle
Cheltenham Town
2
0
 
Final
Sheffield Wednesday
Cheltenham Town
4
1
 
Final
Accrington Stanley
Cheltenham Town
4
4
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Portsmouth
1
0
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Gillingham
2
2
 
Final
Lincoln City
Cheltenham Town
3
0
 
Final
Cheltenham Town
Bolton Wanderers
1
2
 
Final
Cambridge United
Cheltenham Town
2
2