Major League Soccer
 
Ende
Columbus Crew
Montreal Impact
2
1
 
New York RB
Columbus Crew
 
SJ Earthquakes
Columbus Crew
 
Columbus Crew
Cincinnati
 
Columbus Crew
Toronto FC
 
New York City
Columbus Crew
 
Cincinnati
Columbus Crew
 
Columbus Crew
Chicago Fire
 
Atlanta United
Columbus Crew
 
Vancouver Whitecaps
Columbus Crew
 
Columbus Crew
Philadelphia Union
 
Toronto FC
Columbus Crew